I appreciate this Wisconsin-based pizza chain.
Glass Nickel is definitely an upgrade from the likes of Pizza Hut, Domino's, and even Papa John's. As such, the pizzas are also more expensive. I'd call it semi-gourmet fast-food pizza. Their menu is relatively large. I like the spinach cheese bread here and their specialty pizzas aren't bad.
I'd recommend ordering online as Glass Nickel always has coupons to print and coupon codes. You won't necessarily save much, but take what you can get, right?