When I lived in Cleveland this was my favorite ice cream (okay, custard) place, but since it was conveniently close to where I lived I never made a habit of coming here. Now that I no longer live in Cleveland I absolutely have to come here every time I am in town. I introduced my non Ohioan wife to East Coast and she loves it, too.
We never get anything by the vanilla custard on a cone. It is amazingly creamy, has very good vanilla flavor, and is not overly sweet. The malt vanilla shake was too sweet, however.