If you are going in expecting a great pizza, there are better places. If you are going for drinks, great service, good food, in an intimate setting with a few friends, then this may be a good spot. For the most part, every pizza lacked seasoning/flavor except for the one with the truffle oil. The funghi pizza was disappointing - I've had better mushroom pizza at CPK - they used small white mushrooms which lacked flavor and not enough of it.
I believe the reviews are very high for this spot because of HH, drinks, & service, and not because their pizza is amazing. Went with 5 friends and walked away feeling that the pizza was just OK - wouldn't go out of our way to have it again or make a trip there just for the pizza.