It never ceases to amaze me how many people visit a restaurant just as it opens then hit Yelp and hammer them with 2 stars! Everyone knows this industry takes time to work out the kinks and a lot of these reviews are petty and premature! That being said, knowing The Statehouse has been open for over a year they really do an amazing job! Truth be told they have one of the best views of the lake in Madison, but they don't rest on that. They have exceptional service and outstanding food and drinks to boot! Having just visited again last night, their wedge salad is one of the best in town (I know, you're thinking it's just a salad, but trust me and order it), their lobster bisque is drool-worthy, and the chilled crab claws are out of this world.
My advice, take the older reviews with a grain of salt and visit The Statehouse...I truly think you won't be disappointed! But if you're up for something more casual, hit the Boathouse, it's equally as delish!