Still love this place! I've been here several times and always had a great experience. The thin crust is perfectly fired, to the point where it is crispy and crunchy with a beautifully chewy center. I've tried a few of the salads as well as 6 or 7 of the pizzas on the menu, and I've enjoyed everything I have had at PIzza Brutta. It is a little bit pricey, with the cheapest pizzas around $10 and large salads (good for sharing with one or two others) about $8. I recommend ordering a salad and 1-2 pizzas for 2-3 people to share. The service is good and you get your food pretty quickly. Tables can be hard to get when it gets really busy, but people eat and get out fast so you never have to wait long.
Overall one of my favorite places in Madison to go to for delicious, consistent food and service.