Antonio's is our "go-to" for delivered pizza in our area. We are Dormont dwellers and although Antonio's is in Brookline, it's close enough.
We've tried the rest, Antonio's is the one that my sweetie and I agree on.
Tonight we ordered a large pizza and two small orders of wings. (We were not agreeing on the flavor of wings tonight.) Both of us started with our wings tonight, and both of us raved about them. They were perfect, just perfect.
Our pizza got second billing tonight, but it wasn't the pizza's fault. Actually, it was very good. The sauce has some "tang" to it, the toppings are fresh and there are plenty of them. (Tonight we had Pepperoni and mushrooms...)
Often we order their pasta dishes and have never been disappointed. I'm a particular fan of their baked ziti.
I have to point out that their delivery drivers are part of the equation. Although the stand time quoted is 40 minutes, we consistently get our food (in the next neighborhood) within 25 minutes and often within 20. That is very impressive. Admittedly we tip the drivers well every time.
So... If you live in Brookline, Dormont or Beechview and are in the mood for some takeout, ring up Antonio's!