I randomly stopped by here months ago thanks exclusively to Mr K's fascinating list of Phoenix Middle Eastern restaurants. I never got around to reviewing it so memories have faded a bit.
It's a bit hard being objective on Baba-Ganush because the family that owns this place was so welcoming and friendly to me. I was literally the only customer on that mid-week night. What seemed like the family's 13 or 14 year old daughter was my "waitress". So, I felt more like I was a guest in their home rather than a paying customer. When I was finished with my entree (which was good, and filling), she came up to me with a plate of some unknown Arabic dessert I'd never had before, and shyly asked if I'd like to have some for free. It really would have seemed rude had I said no, so I accepted, and it actually tasted pretty good. I still have no idea what it was though.
In one sentence, I'd describe this as a family-owned, somewhat haphazardly run restaurant serving standard Middle Eastern fare. If you're in the area and feeling adventurous, go for it. But don't drive your family from Gilbert to eat here.