I'd say 3 stars in the winter months, and 4 stars during patio season (they have a large back deck with awnings that is quite green and nice for al fresco dining, when weather permits).
The food is casual/rustica Italian and the menu is good for sharing and sampling different things. Most of it is very good, with the occasional miss. The menu features a lot of specials which I rather like as it keeps things interesting/varied if you're a regular.
The service is helpful and friendly. It's an intimate space that is warm and dimly lit. The prices are mid-range and very reasonable for the quality. Overall it's a good meal!