Another classic example of an overrated and overpriced restaurant.
I've been to Otto's twice -- once for a rehearsal dinner and once for a birthday. For the rehearsal dinner, it was a preset menu and although it was technically free, it was just meh. The appetizers were okay, but the entree selections were not enticing at all. At the birthday dinner, I ordered the ribeye steak. It was on the more bland end and the steak was tougher rather than tender. Again, the appetizers were slightly better -- the calamari was standard and the Mediterranean meatballs were okay.
All in all, Otto's food was not absolutely horrible. My diagnosis of overrated and overpriced just means that for the price you pay, there is no doubt you can find better quality and better tasting dishes.