We don't even bother going to other places for pizza anymore these days, for two reasons: the pizza here is really good, and the pizza cookie (but we'll get to that).
The BBQ chicken pizza here is incredible and we never pass it up when we're here. Sometimes we'll branch out and try something else in addition - the Lawrence's Original is good and a nice contrast to the BBQ, although the tomato sauce is pretty salty. We've also tried the Rosemary chicken, the mushroom pizza, and the meat pizza (another standout) and those were good too. My father-in-law swears by the wings. The drinks here are good - I especially recommend sangria or a mimosa. They're not stingy with the alcohol, either. ;)
But the REAL reason to come here is for the pizza cookie. I wish there were words to describe how good it is. Whenever I see a cookie sundae type thing on a menu I'm obligated to try it. I have had pizza cookies near and far. Never once have I had one that could remotely compare to the Oregano's version. It's the best dessert I've ever had, hands down. Sometimes I luck out and my husband is too full to help me finish much of it - rest assured, no matter what, none of it gets wasted. Sometimes I find myself looking up pictures of their pizza cookies online like a teenager furtively checking out the centerfold in a girlie magazine. They're that good. So anyway, give this place a try if you haven't yet! And save room for the cookie at the end!