It's all in what you order. The previous two ice creams I've had were not palatable. I could not finish my items.
Third time's a charm (I don't believe in giving up!). Ordered a vanilla milk shake with peanut butter and hot fudge mixed in with a cheesecake on the stick for later. Both were just right.
I'll keep coming back here in case there are more flavors I like!
P.S. They had Maine Lobster flavored ice cream here last time I went.