I always stop by Stogies when I'm in Montreal. To echo the comments of another reviewer, the place is very different depending on when you go. I prefer it when it is quieter there. The loud club music at night detracts from my enjoyment of the place. But, I get to smoke indoors, in Canada! So I won't complain too much. The selection of drinks is top notch and fairly priced. I highly recommend white port to pair with your cigar. No cutting fees are a bonus too. As long you're drinking, they dont mind people bringing in their own cigars. The walk in humidor has a pretty decent selection for the casual cigar smoker too in all price ranges.
The staff are just fantastic. The ladies are very attentive, strike up conversations and make you feel welcome while there.