3rd visit. Not as good as the other two, because of the service we received from Shandi. It is surprising too because it wasn't as busy as the other times. She seemed preoccupied with cleaning duties (at 7pm ... it's not like it was closing time).
The cheese curds are (still) the best of four times we had them at different places in Madison this trip.
I ordered a pot roast that had no flavor. My coworker who ordered it as well agreed with me; we tried salt and pepper and ended up trying to give it some "oompf" with Worcestershire sauce that Shandi brought us from the kitchen once we tackled her when she occasioned by.
The Jury is out for me if I am going to bring someone else here on my next trip. Madison has too many other places I'd like to try. Ah... but that roasted brussels sprout salad may make me come back. And the cheese curds!