Absolutely disgusting. Pizza was cool when it was delivered (I live two blocks away) so the cheese was already rubbery. It was a pallid shade of grey, and may have actually been rubber. The crust was the same texture. Disturbing. Only twice in my life have I had a pizza so bad I needed to throw most of it out. This was one of those times.
(FYI the other was at Adriatic Restaurant in Manhattan.)