I went in with every intention of eating "the best cheeseburger in town" as advertised on the little sign out front that directs you towards the alley. Once I sat down and looked over the menu, I took a gamble and decided I was in the mood for pasta and went with the spaghetti with a veal meatball.
And you know what? It was SO GOOD. And it was $9! It's a tiny little place with a massive beer selection and a well-stocked bar. The food was pretty slow coming out, but that's probably my fault for ordering from Johnny's main kitchen.
It was late on a Friday night but it wasn't filled with the usual West 6th crowd - and for that I'm very thankful and will definitely be going back.