What a fantastic little place! I love the fact that it is hidden away - you definitely need to know what you are hunting for. And I love all of the old record albums that line the walls and ceiling as you walk in. It's the perfect tiny pizza eatery.
What was the best was the pizza. Yelp had built it up so much that I was a bit nervous. But one bite of my slice of cheese pizza and I was instantly transported back to my days at NYU. It was the perfect slice of NY-style pizza. So hot it burned the roof of my mouth. So greasy that I went through way too many napkins. So big I did the fold maneuver.
And major props for having beer too. Just two handles - Pabst and a Dogfish Head (I didn't see which one). Totally awesome that they have Dogfish Head.
And big ups for having plastic forks and knives available. For this first try, I had to eat with my hands and be all authentic. But typically, I am a knife and fork girl, so I appreciate it when casual eateries with "hand food" also have the proper utensils for those who want them.
Great staff, great food, and great overall vibe (loved the feel, the music, etc.). I will definitely be back,