Sad to have to update my review on this place...
HUGE decline since this past Summer. No longer our favorite local pizza place. The pizza does not taste or look the same, even though they said it hasn't changed. My mouth and eyes tell me otherwise.
Also, the service has went dooooooown. Like, into the gutter. A few weeks ago, we stopped on the way home to get a pie. I rang the doorbell THREE times. I saw two people in the back, but no one came, so we left. This weekend, we thought we'd order, but they didn't answer their phone.
That was probably our last attempt for Ohio City Pizza. If you guys get it together over there, let us know.