Being new in town, I called maybe my second day for delivery. I ordered their French dip and absolutely loved it. We stopped by the other night and grabbed a pie of pizza. As a born and raised New Yorker, I'm pretty judgmental on pizza and am very picky.
Although I haven't seen claims of Stumpy's modeling their pizza after NY pizza like most business do out here (and epically fail), I think their pizza is phenomenal and definitely the best in town. It may not be New York-good as far as my absolute favorite places in NY, but very close and comparable to the pizza I grew up eating. For a great price this is definitely my go-to neighborhood pizza and sandwich place!