I enjoy Joeys, esp. if you are looking for some place quiet.
Whenever I have been in there my guests and I are the only ones in the place. I actually spent my 21st birthday dinner here. The owner is really nice and remembers my name each time I'm there, in fact he is almost always the person who takes my order.
I do agree that the prices should come down a bit..
The service will keep me coming back. I don't really get the creepy vibe that the other reviewers got but then again I didn't take the vegetarian house as a cult either..
Its excellent for dates you actually want to talk to, its been a cure for the restaurants that I can't even hear my guest speak.
I must say, if you do go and enjoy liquor try the lemon cello. The owner makes it from scratch and its even better when you dip cannolis in it.