Update #2! Upgrading to 5 stars! We tried refrigerating the cookies and, wow, what a difference that made. I'd definitely recommend them now! The cooler temperature seemed to give them a bit more heft, and the icing is the consistency that I really like now -- not too hard, but not super messy either. So if at first you don't think you like these cookies, try refrigerating them for 5+ hours, and see if that makes a difference. So glad we gave them another chance -- yummy! I think the heat just did a number on them, but cooling them down changed our minds.
Another thing is that we thought the flavor of every single cookie was really great. So no matter what your preference is, you're bound to find something you'll enjoy!
We would definitely return!