Scallywags deserves a solid 4* at the very least for the unique atmosphere it offers.
I find Scally to be by far the best place in TO for watching soccer (especially EPL). The fans are passionate, and the establishment understands knows exactly how to cater to them. Scally offers a no non-sense menu that has been just OK in my personal view. The farmer's breakie, and goat cheese omelete are the two items I have enjoyed more than others, though I often settle for only tea.
The service is great if you happen to be served by the Scally old guard! Overall, I would suggest ordering only drinks when it's too busy as the kitchen can get backed up during busy fixtures. One fella who makes a huge difference at Scally is Pedro. Even during the busiest games he is always quick, courteous, and professional, and this is no small feat considering how crazy this place can get at 7 a.m. on a Sunday morning!