I don't see how this is only 3.5 stars. In fact If my friend hadn't told me to try it I wouldn't have because of the Yelp reviews. I will have to say that this is the one time I have experienced that Yelp got it wrong.
We were able to sit at the bar a few minutes before our reservation and the bartender told us about the beef cheek ravioli and the rib eye for one. Both of these items are not in the menu but well worth it. The rib eye for one was enough for me and my wife to share. The server brings it out and cuts up the rib eye and describes all the parts. I will admit on our next visit I will just get the ribeye for two because I don't want to have a shortage of the most tender parts of the steak. I would definitely recommend Carnevino to anyone!