MUST UPGRADE REVIEW TO FIVE STARS FOR IAN'S PIZZA AND THEIR HEROIC SUPPORT OF WISCONSIN PROTESTERS.
Arrived at about 1:30 AM and was pleasantly surprised by the absence of any line. Tried the macaroni and cheese slice, as well as a sausage and pepperoni slice. Both were good, but the macaroni and cheese slice was extra special -- although be prepared for a rich mix of cheeses if your stomach is not in top shape after consuming adult beverages.
The self-service water fountain was a nice feature, as was the plentiful seating. For a busy pizza shop on a college street loaded with bars, the restaurant was nice and clean, too.