I went to Reposado with a group of friends on a Friday night in July. I really enjoy drinking tequila and the reviews on Yelp and Toronto Life compelled me to check it out.
Their selection of tequila is impressive. I asked the bartender's opinion on a few choices and he seemed knowledgeable enough. To be honest, a lot of their opinions sound very similar so if you're a complete beginner, don't expect to be given a Tequila 101. Just ask for an ounce of something anejo and you'll be fine. Don't sip the silver stuff unless you like making ridiculous faces in public.
I'm not sure if it was because of the numerous drinks I was having, or whether it was the impending heat wave in Toronto, but the bar was sweltering. I felt like I was sweating tequila bullets. There's outdoor space in the back for a patio, but there are walls surrounding the seating area so there is no breeze or wind at all. It was an improvement from indoors, but still not that comfortable. If you're going to be on a date, just don't wear something that will show your sweat marks!
The bar was busy but not too crowded. There was a friendly crowd there and the ambiance was cozy. It's not the cheapest place to have drinks but it is definitely unique and worth revisiting.
I tried the Don Julio 1942 Anejo and it was damned good (it's not actually made in 1942 though). For a 1.5 oz shot, it was $25. Instead of trying to pick tequilas based on how cool their bottle is, you can ask for a menu which lists all the options and their prices (the latter is important because we ordered a lot of the 1942 before we discovered the price).