I can't give any restaurant a five star as I have nothing to compare it to but definately a 4+. Very surprised to find an unpretentious menu in such an upscale spot. It was raining and we had resigned ourselves to Whole Foods takeout but fortunately for us WF closed before we got there and we walked across the street to Cibo. GREAT choice. We had the tomato salad, spaghetti with meat balls, and a pizza. A previous review was correct, full size pizza we could have shared but I loved the non Prego sauce. I expected large, tough, meat balls but received a bunch of little, gentle meat balls. A dish easy to ruin, I have done it often, but Cibo's was perfect. I had to ask for a soup spoon to twirl the spaghetti, the way I was taught, but I guess people don't learn that way now days. We will be here another week and I hope we get back to Cibo.