OHHHHHHH Yes!!!
Literally its like Eureka several nights a month for me. Hands down the closest thing I have found to a NYC Style slice of pizza. Beware thou... they do not sell slices on Friday nights or the weekend. But they do pack an absolute punch when it comes to small dinners. They have 4 or 5 variety's of small Italian dinners for under $5.50. I often grab the lasagna with tomato sauce ( which comes with garlicky bread), but the mancotti, stuffed shells and meatballs are all delicious.
This little joint is a hidden gem... it usually has at least half of the tables filled and a bubbly personality at the counter to help with orders.
Sicilian Slice is decent... very decent... best I have found in Charlotte - its definitely worth the try and if your in the south Charlotte area and considering it... try it.
Before I forget.. dare I say.. they have... AUTHENTIC TIRAMISU !!!! its awesome.