Been back quite a few times since my first review, and I'm still their biggest fan. This is the little out of the way place I recommend to my friends to bring their out of town visitors to impress them with the foodie side of Madison. The seafood is always excellent. They had a duck special last time that was on point, and their wine list is perfectly sized for the location. I have no reservations about recommending this place to anyone.
Also. If you get a chance to get their mulled wine--do it. Oooooh. So greattt.