The restaurant has great ambiance and great service, and the food is serviceable. My rating is more along the lines of 3.5 stars. I appreciate that they offer free breadsticks with two dipping sauces, and with your entree you get the choice of minestrone soup, house salad, or Caesar salad.
The breadsticks were okay, they would be bland without the dipping sauces (marinara and alfredo). The soup came with lots of ingredients but lacked depth of flavor. I had the Fruitti de Mar pasta which came with 3 shrimp, 3 calamari, 5 mussels and about 7-8 clams. The seafood was delicious but the pasta was bleh. I wish the pasta sauce was thicker and clung better to the pasta.
It's not a bad place, there's just nothing to make it stand out amongst the hundreds of Italian restaurants in town.