I love preloved! While some of the styles here can be hit or miss, I love the concept and the one-of-a-kind gems you'll find here. This location is quite popular, so I prefer their "pop-up" location on Danforth, which has a selection that's much less picked-over (not to mention has more stuff in sizes L and XL for people like me that are not-so-svelte).
The stuff here is pricey, but a) it's locally made, and b) the workmanship is great. The items aren't sewn or constructed cheaply and every piece is definitely made with love. At this time, lots of stuff is on sale so you can pick up something pretty for a discount. That said, I do wish more of their pieces were universally flattering - the silhouettes tend to work best for those who are tall and skinny - but I think everyone can find something here.