I would actually give it a 4.5 but that wasn't an option. This is the second time I have eaten here and both times I have not been disappointed with the food. I love the fact that the ingredients come from local vendors. If you are a foodie this is definitely a place that you need to try, but reservations are a MUST.
Atlas is a hidden gem within a strip mall complex, part of AZ Wine Store. I enjoy the ambiance of the restaurant and the fact that it is limited to about 10 tables. It is fun to be able to bring in our favorite wines to enjoy with the meal and you can always go buy a bottle once you decide on your meal. The service is a little to slow though, which is why I took off half a star. Granted I don't like to be rushed, but the time it took from being seated to actually taking our order seemed like a bit much. Once we ordered most of the courses came out well timed but there was a bit of a wait again between finishing our meal and them checking to see if we would like dessert.
Overall, I would be happy to eat here again.