The 3 or so times I've had these cupcakes have been pretty consistent-- artificial-tasting flavours, dry cupcakes, and icing that seemed too rich and overly sweet. It may be that they haven't been made fresh rather than the way they bake them.
An odd thing friends and I would always comment on is that we felt incredibly thirsty after just one bite of their cupcakes. Pricey, poor taste, uncomfortable to eat. Try another local bakery.