5Church certainly has a lot of hype. It seems to pride itself on being glamorous and chic. In my opinion, the food puts way more emphasis on form then taste. Great example, is a scallop dish was plated incredibly fancy, but the scallops were under-cooked and the favors didn't meld well. All in all, the dish fell flat.
They did have some good small plates - think tapas - and that is the only thing that prevented it from getting one star.
If you want a fancy place with bad food, this is the spot for you. If you like tasty food, I'd look somewhere else.