5 stars - for the prepared foods. B.E.S.T. tacos we have had since moving to Ohio. They're like the taco carts/trucks on each corner under the 7 train along Roosevelt Ave in Queens (NYC). DELICIOUS! Finger licking good! We regularly come to La Plaza, and it never disappoints! We've brought many first timers here, and each time they'll text a few days later, "Can you send me the name/address of that taco place?" The tamales are SLAMMIN'! The bakery is on point. (Disclosure - we've never had a cake from here.)
4 stars - for Mexican groceries. I don't cook Mexican food, so my assessment may not be accurate. But it "looks" like it'd have every ingredient needed/wanted. We definitely pick up a few "novelty" groceries each time we come.
4 stars - for the produce - the variety is fresh and varied, but limited. I can pick up specific items but have never been able to only shop here for all my week's produce needs. When I buy produce here, its only as a supplement for specific dishes.