I'd heard and read nothing but positive things from sources I trust (Sources I trust: Friends, Globe and Mail, Joanne Kates. Sources I don't trust: 905ers on Yelp.), but Foxley always seemed to fly a little under my radar when it actually came time to answer the question "What to eat tonight?"
I finally gave it a try and was very impressed, despite the polarizing reviews. For what it's worth, we took most of our server's recommendations and ordered: the crab and avocado salad; a Lao-style spicy beef salad; a wahoo and peach ceviche; fried shrimp with jalapenos and garlic; and red curry beef cheek. I thought the curry lacked some depth and spice but everything else was great, particularly the fish ceviche and crispy shrimp.
Portions are ample. I can (and do, with alarming regularity) take down a large pizza myself in 20 minutes when I'm hungry and I left Foxley very full. You should be pretty satisfied ordering 5 dishes between two people. By my math that's about $80 of food -- not exactly breaking the bank, so people here should stop complaining about portion sizes and just order one more dish for $12-$16 if you're still hungry.
Service was really friendly and the back patio is a great place to sit on a summer night. (Not too many left, unfortunately.) I will definitely be adding Foxley to my rotation.