Indie is one of my favorite coffee spots in Madison. The coffee drinks are superb and all sourced well, which is important to me.
Go ahead and have anything on the menu! It's all made to order and tasty. The real treat is their waffle menu. While it's not elaborate, it's delicious! You receive e a dollar off on Waffle Wednesday when purchasing a beverage too.
The space is super tight but I don't really mind, and there is a nice, cozy back porch open when the weather is warm. The events are fun too.
My only critiques would be the salads leave a lot to be desired. They are basic and just not what I would want to pay $6+ to eat.
Pro tip: Their to-go hot beverage cups leak from the lid. This is unavoidable, so watch for spills on your hand and sleeves and grab a napkin.