I'm not that picky when it comes to baked goods. Put enough sugar in it and it'll pass in my book...with one exception. Frosting. Very few can beat Giant Eagle's buttercream (truth) but if you don't even come close, there's a problem. And PC's doesn't come close, unfortunately. The good news is, their donuts are GOOD. Go for the donuts and you'll be happy. I'd probably skip the cakes and cookies but you might like'em!