I had my wedding after party at Brocach and while I had a fabulous time, I unfortunately cannot provide a good review of the venue.
1) The music was inaudible and they would not turn up the music even after several requests and promises to do so.
2) Even though bar close is listed as 2am (on Yelp) and we still had dozens of people present, they closed the bar around midnight on a Saturday.
3) There was some confusion about tip being included on our bar tab and even though the general manager Marcos Jimenez assured us repeatedly that we could get reimbursed he has been non-responsive to e-mails and phone calls and we have not received the reimbursement more than a month later.
We loved the location on the square and the upstairs area is free to reserve and quite spacious. We had a great time despite the annoyances listed above but would definitely not recommend it for the above reasons. if Marcos ever follows through with issue #3 we'd consider increasing our rating to two or three stars.