I would have originally given Dr. Gellar a 3 star rating, I felt his appointments were extremely short and a lot of guess work was involved in the diagnosis. That being said I'm no doctor and for all I know he could have been spot on, I don't know because my pain continues and I will be seeing a different Doctor. Dr Gellar and I saw each other 3 times, 2 for X-rays (15 min appointments at the most) and once was a simple how does it feel and keep wearing your boot (less than 5 total min.). He discussed surgery with me briefly saying if the pain continues he could go in and clean it up, never mentioned an MRI to check for ligament damage. At that point I decided I would not be seeing Dr Gellar again.
The reason I dropped the review from 3 stars to 1 is I feel Dr. Gellar took advantage of me and my insurance by billing for a full appointment on my less than 5 min visit that could have easily taken place via phone. On that visit, which was the middle of the three, I was not asked to pay the co-pay and if I was I would have disputed it immediately. The other two appointments I was asked to pay before leaving and I did so. I hope this helps, the lady that works in his office is very nice but I would never recommend Dr. Gellar to anyone.