Mellow Mushroom just never disappoints. NEVER.
Yes, I know it is a chain and you can find them anywhere, but it is so consistent and so good. The staff is always happy to help, and you can tell they are happy to work there.
My new favorite is the Holy Shitake pie. Holy sh** (no pun intended) it is good. Mushrooms and truffle, and aoli what else could you want? Their crust is dense but delicious. Sprinkled with parmesan and good to the last bite. The dough is on point. We had the bruschetta this visit, and it was good as well. You can also never go wrong with Kosmic Karma or the Mighty Meaty.
Also, they always have a great beer selection and good specials throughout the week.
Honestly, I have had a hard time finding pizza this good in town, even at local places.