Went for my bday last week. Early in the evening. Service was really slow. Painfully slow. They were however really friendly....
Appetizers were good. Drinks were good. You call yourself the Montauk? The Lobster rolls were a joke, you really need to revisit this menu item. Tiny fishy pieces of lobster, nothing like you would see back east. Not even close. Really disappointed in that. Unlikely I would go back or recommend. More clubby than restaurant.