This place ROCKS. Used to live in the Valley and back this weekend for Spring Training (Go Giants!). Happened upon Baxter's the morning before going to the game for a pre-game cigar. Fortunate enough to meet Joe and (the smokin' hot) Madie. ;-)
Friendly, unpretentious and welcoming. Will be returning to see the action at night. If you're looking for a place with a great selection of cigars and a place that you will feel welcome, regardless if you're a regular or a first timer, hit up Baxter's. You won't regret it.