My boyfriend and I have been going to Fatheads now for about 2 years. Since we live right down the street we are able to go there quite often, which is both a blessing and a curse. I absolutely love it! It is easily one of my favorite places. I've had almost everything on the menu and I have never been disappointed. You can't go wrong with any of the Headwiches or the pizzas. They have these smoke house wings that are gigantic and this beastly BBQ sauce to smother them in that's out of this world. I'm addicted to their chips and this sandwich called the Breuben (it's like a Reuben, but better). There's defiantly a lot to choose from.
Fatheads isn't just about delicious food though. They also have some of the greatest local beers. I especially like their Headhunter IPA and I think that their Christmas ale rivals Great Lakes. They have a kind of beer for everyone, from Belgians to stouts, even some Iambics. The atmosphere is cool, unless you go in there on a weekend night and it's madhouse with a two hour wait for a table. Their only downfall is the parking lot. It's way too small for the capacity of the place. On a busy night you'll end up trekking from the Drug Mart parking lot.
I'd recommend this place to anyone.