I received a very nice message from the owner. I really appreciate his effort in researching the situation and defending his business in a polite and professional manner so I'm updating my review.
It turns out the attendant I dealt with that day misspoke-- I was over by 40 minutes. He must have been having an off day because I asked twice and even repeated back, "40 seconds," to him.
Anyhow, I plan on giving Blue Sky another chance as all other experiences were good and the owner made a very valiant effort to make amends. All other business owners should take note when a less than desirable review is written by a customer. Thanks again, Blue Sky! I'll be seeing you again soon.
Will update with a 5* if the next few visits go well.