If they were selling $1 cupcakes I'd give them 3 Stars. But they're asking a premium for small cupcakes. The cupcakes themselves are hard, dry and relatively flavorless. Frankly, you can get better cupcakes (just the cake portion) at Harris Teeter. The icing is usually very good. It's a rich butter cream frosting. When they get a flavor right, it's good. When they get it wrong, which is about 50-50, it's not so great.
We tried them 3 times based on feedback from friends and were pleased once. The other two times we'd rather have had something from a grocery store or just about anywhere else.