The Garage has existed in Eau Claire Market for about as long as Eau Claire Market has existed. When I was a kid, I used to peer in when we visited the food court and wish with all my being that I be allowed inside. I just looked so... COOL.
Now that I am older and have been a grand total of three times, I can say that either times have changed or I have because I'm pretty lukewarm. The pool tables are cool, but not enough of a draw considering the prices and atmosphere which is... decent. The service has been ok all three times, but we were always mildly neglected after the initial order. It's really frustrating when you're all prepared to order and then you have to wait fifteen minutes, then another ten (at least) for them to bring you your order.
The sandwich I had placed firmly in the "It's ok" category.
The place is still pretty interesting looking, being a converted garage. Not nearly as cool as my six year old mind might have imagined.