We decided to try Bagels Forever for breakfast last weekend on our way out to Middleton. The store is easiest to get to if you are traveling east. We had to do a U-turn on University to arrive from the east. Then heading west we had to take some back-roads until we got to a light to turn left on university. Minor travail.
Once inside they have numerous bagels and toppings to choose from. The cashier taking our order was on the surly side. He just stood there. Didn't ask if he could take our order or help us. I know it's hard to be 'on' all the time, but even a 'hi' would have been nice.
That being said, the prices were exceptional. It felt like half the price I pay at other bagel joints. The bagels were slightly smaller than other bagel eateries but my sandwich with egg, turkey pastrami, and cheese was very tasty and not impactful to my wallet so I was very pleased.
Although not super convenient location for me, if I'm in the area, I'll definitely stop by again.