Best Pizza in town. From Sun Prairie, to Monona, to Middleton, to Verona, this is my favorite spot surrounding Madison. Food is great here and my wife and I order weekly on Friday nights.
I will say this place gets PACKED and I always order take-out (which can be 30-40 minutes on a busy night). I've dined in a couple of times, the atmosphere is fine and very clean, but nothing worth dining in for if you can just take it home.
Moving soon and know that I won't find another pizza place as great as this one :(