I want to adore the Neighborhood Theater, I really do. As a music venue, it gives me all that I could ask for. If you are willing to shell out for VIP tickets, more than you would normally ask for, like a charming woman who brings you your beer from the bar so you don't miss a number. They also regularly host the All Arts Market which is a great place for local artists to show off their absolute awesomeness and for local consumers to buy unique pieces to display in their homes. Do you want a beer while you groove or shop? They have a great mix of local craft brews (obviously along with the big beer standards) for you purchase for less than 5 bones.
I want to adore the Neighborhood but I merely like it.
I guess the fact that parking can be a pain (there are spaces on the street but the lot behind is $3 pretty much all the time) and the schedule is less my taste than other spaces in town pulls my cursor from the 5 star range to the 4 star range.
Maybe you disagree with me though, so I do suggest you try it out for yourself.