Your experience is almost completely dependent on who's playing the organ on any given night. If you have the misfortune of Charlie Balogh, it's your own fault because you should have checked the schedule before you went. You will more than likely hear songs composed no later than 1968 which is fine if you're between 75-100 years old. While there's a box for requests, it might as well lead to a paper shredder because Charlie prefers to play whatever he wants to hear or perhaps only what he knows how to play. Try to keep requests simple and maybe they might get played, Mary Had a Little Lamb, Pop Goes the Weasel, etc.