My fiancee and I stopped in for dinner one night after wanting to try Jammy Buggars for a while, and were severely underwhelmed. The best part about the entire dinner was the stuffed mushroom appetizer. Man were those caps good! BUT (and this is a big but), there were only 3 stuffed mushrooms on the plate. For 8.50, I at the very least should not have to knife and fork the last cap to ensure two people get an equal share. That kind of set the mode of the entire dinner experience.
However the burgers were severely mediocre. My fiancees tasted like a block of salted meat (she had the Juicy Jim) and mine just had some odd, oniony flavor (I had the Gourmet) - it was not good. The beer selection, I found also left something to be desired.
It just wasn't good enough to justify a $45+ bill. I most likely won't be coming back here, not with all the other awesome places to try around Cleveland.